|
Sunday, April 18, 2010
Over the years I've been guided by the wisdom of Thomas Keating, the Benedictine monk whose writings and teachings about a method of prayer called Centering Prayer have informed my life in powerful ways. "It's the intention that matters," he has said in about a zillion different ways to emphasize the truth that we may do our spiritual practice imperfectly, but it is why we are doing what we do that matters.
I think that the same wisdom applies to giving, and that wisdom has come back to me repeatedly since Wednesday's posting in which I placed narcissism and self-absorption in a juxtaposition with reciprocity. The stirring of responses has generated a good deal of self-examination for me, as well as a lifetime of memories of giving for the wrong reasons.
Finding a healthy balance between giving and receiving is an on-going process. It's not fixed, but fluid throughout our lives. That I can be so unconscious about my own motivations continues to disturb me, even after years of efforts to stay awake and aware of what it is that moves me to do what I do and to give what I give. In thinking about others' response to what I wrote in the blog, I've asked myself these questions:
-- What is the difference in the way I feel when I give in order to meet my own needs and when I give to meet the needs of the other person?
-- How much of my giving is motivated by my own needs? And just what needs am I trying to get met by my giving?
-- Am I giving what I want, hoping to get it back?
-- Am I giving what I never had, whether or not it is what the other wants or needs?
-- Do I burden my gifts with unspoken expectations of how the other will respond to my gift, or am I able to allow the other person to receive and respond as he or she can or does?
-- Am I giving out of the overflow of my own love for a person, or am I giving out of duty or obligation?
-- Is my giving motivated out of people-pleasing or to placate, appease or manipulate the other person or maybe even God?
-- What am I hoping to get back when I give?
-- Do I ever give out of a motivation of guilt, hoping the person will forget something I've done that was unloving, thoughtless or even hurtful?
-- How do I feel when I give either time, money or gifts because it is expected of me?
-- How do I feel when others continue to expect me to give, regardless of how I am feeling or whether I have what they are demanding or not?
-- When is it that I give out of codependence, and when and to whom do I give out of delight in bestowing something the other will enjoy or find meaningful?
-- When someone doesn't respond to my gift in the way I would like, what do I do? What do I feel?
-- What does it feel like when I give with a hidden agenda?
-- Do I give in order to look good, polish my image or curry favor with someone? If I do, how does that feel?
-- What is it ike when I give out of freedom -- out of joy and pleasure -- with no strings attached?
Here's what i've learned, and I've learned it the hard way. I've had to have repeated lessons to get the message, and I don't ever dare say that I've finally gotten the lesson:
-- While no motivation is rarely pure and untainted by my mixed motives, it is that giving out of obligation and duty or giving that is motivated by fear, guilt or the need to please, placate or appease the recipient that wears me out, drains my energy and sucks the life out of my soul, leaving me depleted and often resentful.
-- When I give anything to make myself look good, to polish up my image or to advance my own ego-driven needs, that giving will wear me out.
-- Healthy relationships require and thrive in reciprocity. However, reciprocity is not the same as "I give in order to get" or "I'll do this if you'll do that." Reciprocity flows freely. It is not coercion.
-- Giving that is life-giving and soul-nourishing flows freely from the giver, reflects the nature and character of the giver and meets the need of the other. I remember that memory verse I learned when I was a child: God loves a cheerful giver.
-- Not giving-- either a common courtesy or the gift of yourself, your talents or your resources-- withholding, stinginess and selfishness starves and deprives the soul of the gifts that come from freely giving to others.
-- Generosity, genius, generativity -- all come from the same root word, and they all keep life flourishing.
-- We are stewards of our resources, remember? Giving is good for us, and we are stewards of what we give, where we give it and in what measure.
-- When my giving is more about me than it is the welfare or happiness of the other, or when I'm giving to draw attention to myself, I will feel empty and depleted, but when I give out of the overflow of love, I will know that it really is better to give than it is to receive.
I'm reminded of a sermon my father preached when I was a little girl. It was entitled, "Am I a Liberal?" and of course that sermon had three points. "I hope I am," my dad said. "I hope I am liberal in loving. I hope I am liberal in giving. And I hope I am liberal in forgiving."
Me, too.
Grace to you --
Jeanie
|